Mikhail Khodorkovsky - How Do You Slay A Dragon

in politics”, then just stand on the sidelines and wait. Maybe they’ll be in a good mood and be so kind that they’ll give you something; but with the way things are today it’s more likely that they’ll kick you down and you’ll be the last to be carried off.

But if, on the other hand, you really want to stand up for your rights and the rights of others, then that means getting involved in genuine politics. It means making choices, and it means standing up to be counted, with all the risks that this brings.

I occupy a unique place amongst the ranks of the opposition (true, this doesn’t exactly make me jump for joy). I have huge managerial experience, having worked in the government and at the head of a number of the country’s largest companies, companies that were of strategic significance to the country, and that were linked to dozens of towns and villages which were solely devoted to these industries. But despite all this, I am deprived of the opportunity to carry out practical organisational work on the ground.

When they kicked me out of the country, the authorities slammed the door shut behind me and turned the key, making it absolutely clear that in the event of my returning I would face the rest of my life in prison.

At the same time, I am one of the very few who has personal experience (we could say, “fortunately, very few”, although this experience came with a high price) who has actually told Vladimir Putin to his face exactly what I think about corruption at the highest levels of government. And just a month after doing this I faced criminal charges and ended up being locked up for more than ten years (six in a prison cell and four in a labour camp). Added to which I staged four hunger strikes, including two where I refused to take even liquids; and I carried out all of them – until my demands were met in the case of three of them – as a sign of solidarity.

Ten years. That’s almost as much as my friend, Platon Lebedev. It’s immeasurably less than my colleague, Alexei Pichugin, who’s still in jail. It’s easier than the fate that befell another of my colleagues , the lawyer Vasily Alexanyan, who only a year after his release died from a disease for which he was refused treatment while in prison…

I have something to put before these authorities; some things that will be remembered and some things that must never be forgotten.

But this is exactly why I don’t want to talk about the past; rather, I suggest that we look to the future.

I don’t believe I have the right to juxtapose justice and mercy; to forgive or to refuse to forgive those whom I consider should be punished.

I certainly don’t consider myself to be the bearer of the ultimate truth.

Each one of us has his or her own experience, our own scores to settle and our own thoughts on the future. But by virtue of the way in which my mind works I have decided not simply to consider that, well, “it wouldn’t be bad if we were to change those who are in power”. I’ve constructed a practical plan of action as to what to do “after Putin”.

From the way in which I think of time (and I look on time differently after the period I spent in prison) I believe that this regime does not have much time left: no more than five or ten years. How it’s going to end, I don’t know. Probably along with Putin. After all that has happened in Ukraine, I find it very difficult to imagine that he will step down of his own choice and live out however much time God grants him on some paradise island somewhere. He simply won’t be allowed to do that.

One way or another, this regime will meet its end. When it does, there will be so much that will have to be put right! And it has to be done quickly. It would be wonderful if, when this moment arrives, society has already decided who we are and where we’re heading; in which direction our road is leading in this rapidly changing world…

 

 

Contents

 

Preface

Introduction to the Study of Dragons. My Path into Politics and What I Hope to Achieve

PART I: HOW DO YOU RID YOURSELF OF AN OLD DRAGON?

Chapter 1. The Strategy for Victory: Peaceful Protest, or Peaceful Uprising?

Chapter 2. Bringing the Protesters Together: Many Parties or a Single Party?

Chapter 3. How to Expand the Protest: Underground or In Emigration?

Chapter 4. The Point of No Return: the Street or the Commanding Heights?

Chapter 5. How to Organise the New Order: Constitutional Democracy or Democracy by Decree?

Chapter 6. How to Bring an End to the War: Fight to a Victorious Outcome, Capitulate or Seek a Compromise?

Chapter 7. How to Defeat an Internal Counter-Revolution: Purge the Old Guard or Try to Correct Them?

Chapter 8. How to Control the Man with a Gun: a Task for the Party or for the Secret Services?

Chapter 9. How to Create a Civil Service: Employ Our Own Weak Staff or the Best from Abroad?

Chapter 10. What’s Meant by “a Turn to the Left”: a Welfare State or a Socialist State?

Chapter 11. How Do We Achieve Economic Justice: Nationalisation or Honest Privatisation?

 

 

PART II: HOW DO WE AVOID CREATING A NEW DRAGON?

Chapter 12. The Choice of Civilisation: An Empire or a Nation State?

Chapter 13. The Geopolitical Choice: To Be a Superpower or To Consider the National Interests?

Chapter 14. The Historical Choice: Muscovy or Gardarika (which has nothing to do with Gaidar)?

Chapter 15. The Political Choice: Democracy? Or a Return to the Terror of the Oprichnina?

Chapter 16. The Economic Choice: Monopoly or Competition?

Chapter 17. The Social Choice: a Turn to the Left or a Turn to the Right?

Chapter 18. The Intellectual Choice: Freedom of Speech or Openness that’s Shackled?

Chapter 19. The Constitutional Choice: a Parliamentary Republic or a Presidential One?

Chapter 20. The Legal Choice: the Dictatorship of the Law or a State Based on the Rule of Law?

Chapter 21. The Moral Choice: Justice or Mercy?

Conclusion. The Dragon in Custody

 

Introduction to the Study of Dragons.

My Path into Politics and What I Hope to Achieve

 

Politics was never important for me in and of itself. Before I found myself locked up, I was involved in politics only inasmuch as I needed it for business; in other words, simply to achieve those economic goals that were my priority at the time. Then came prison. Prison is hardly the optimum place to discuss politics; but it’s a good place to receive a political education. And this was what I earnestly strove to achieve when I wasn’t occupied with the other tasks that are put upon you when you’re in jail.

At the very end of 2013, Putin took the decision to release me. Even though, as they say, “hope dies last”, I considered the likelihood of such an outcome to my ten years of incarceration as highly unlikely. To this day I genuinely have no idea what guided Putin’s thinking. Probably there was a number of different reasons. There was the forthcoming Winter Olympics in Sochi, which he knew had to pass off in exemplary

--">